LetterAgent
Mail physical letters by just asking your AI assistant.
Home > Guides > Warranty replacement duties
Usually you should not pay full duties twice, but whether you pay anything at all depends on how the replacement is declared. A free warranty replacement shipped from abroad can still be assessed if customs treats it like a new purchase. Declaring it honestly as a warranty replacement, with the claim number attached, keeps the bill down.
This is general information, not tax advice.
| Scenario | How customs sees it | What to declare |
|---|---|---|
| Seller ships a free replacement under warranty | Goods entering the country; duties possible on the replacement's value | "Warranty replacement, no charge" with the RMA or claim number and a copy of the original invoice |
| You send an item abroad for repair and it comes back | Your own goods returning; duties may apply to the repair value only, not the whole item | "Repaired goods returning" with the repair invoice showing what the work cost |
| Replacement arrives while you return the defective item | Two separate movements; the return may qualify for duty drawback | Declare the replacement as above; keep the return tracking for a drawback claim |
Sometimes, and it is almost always a paperwork problem rather than a law problem. The replacement is free to you, but customs does not tax your wallet: it taxes goods crossing the border. If the seller's shipping department declares the replacement like any other sale, with a full commercial value and no mention of warranty, customs assesses it like any other sale. The fix happens before the parcel ships. Ask the seller to mark the customs form as a warranty replacement with no charge, include the warranty claim or RMA number, and attach a copy of your original purchase invoice. That paper trail is what tells the officer this item replaces something you already paid duties on once.
This is the friendlier case. When you send your own goods abroad for repair and they return, many customs regimes assess duties on the value of the repair, not on the full value of the item. A laptop worth four figures that needed a modest board repair is dutiable on the repair cost. The catch is proof: keep the repair invoice that shows exactly what the work cost, and declare the goods as repaired items returning to their owner. Without that invoice, the officer has no way to separate the repair value from the item value, and you get assessed on the whole thing.
Three things, every time. First, the plain-language reason: "warranty replacement, no charge" or "repaired goods returning to owner." Second, the reference: the RMA number, warranty claim number, or repair order number. Third, the history: a copy of the original purchase invoice, or the original export paperwork if you sent the item out for repair. Do not declare the value as zero with no explanation. A zero with context is a warranty replacement; a zero with no context looks like someone hiding the real value, and customs will assign one for you. The declared value on a free replacement is typically the cost of the replacement unit itself, which is honest and defensible.
Read the bill before you pay it. Courier duty bills often bundle two separate things: the actual government duties and taxes, and the courier's own brokerage fee for doing the clearance. The brokerage fee is the courier's charge, not a tax, and it is calculated on the value the courier declared. If the declaration was wrong, contact the seller first: they can often issue corrected paperwork, and some couriers will re-file. If the duties themselves look wrong, you can dispute the assessment with the customs agency. Keep every document: the claim approval email, the RMA, the original invoice, and the shipping paperwork. Disputes are won on paper, not on phone calls.
Ready to ship it? Get a shipping label with LetterAgent: describe it to your AI assistant, approve the exact quoted price, and get your label.
LetterAgent is a working name. Prices include print, postage, and our service fee. US prices in USD, Canadian prices in CAD (Canadian prices exclude applicable sales tax, added at checkout). Currently in private testing.
Need help? Ask your assistant: it can check a job's status any time. If it ever can't handle something: hello@getletteragent.com