LetterAgent
Mail physical letters by just asking your AI assistant.
Home > Guides > Character reference
A character reference for court is a short letter to the judge describing who the defendant is outside this case: who you are, how long you've known them, and specific examples of their good conduct. Keep it honest, brief, and factual. Never discuss guilt, the charges, or what you think the sentence should be.
This is general information, not legal advice.
| Include | Leave out |
|---|---|
| Your full name, occupation, and contact information | Any discussion of guilt, innocence, or the facts of the case |
| How long you've known the defendant and in what capacity | Opinions about the charges or the alleged victim |
| Specific examples of good conduct: work ethic, caregiving, community involvement | What you think the sentence should be |
| An honest acknowledgment that you know about the case | Exaggeration or claims you can't back up |
Judges read these letters at sentencing, and they read a lot of them. What cuts through is specificity. "He is a good person" is filler; every letter says that. "She has driven my elderly mother to chemotherapy every Tuesday for two years" is evidence. The judge is trying to answer one question: is this offense out of character, or is it the pattern? Your job is to supply the data points that answer it, from your own direct experience.
State your relationship plainly and don't inflate it. A coworker of six months should say so; a friend of twenty years should say so. Judges weight long, close relationships more heavily, but an honest short relationship beats a padded one every time. If the defense attorney asked you to write, say that too; it is normal and expected.
Never discuss the case itself. Don't argue the defendant is innocent, don't minimize the charges, and don't criticize the verdict or the process. That is the defense attorney's job, and your amateur version of it will irritate the judge rather than help. The single most damaging sentence in a character letter is any version of "he didn't really do it": it tells the judge you don't take the conviction seriously, which makes everything else you wrote suspect.
Never tell the judge what sentence to impose. "Please give him probation" oversteps your role and reads as pressure. You can describe the defendant's responsibilities (children, an ailing parent, employees who depend on them) and let the judge draw the conclusions. Facts persuade; requests annoy.
The best writers are people whose standing is obvious: an employer, a teacher, a coach, a member of the clergy, a longtime neighbor. What matters is that the writer has seen the defendant's conduct up close and has nothing to gain from the outcome. Fellow defendants and close family members can write, but judges discount them, for opposite reasons: one group looks self-interested, the other looks biased by love. If the choice is between a lukewarm letter from an impressive title and a warm, specific letter from an ordinary neighbor, take the neighbor. Specificity beats stationery every time.
One page, typed, signed by hand. Address it to "The Honorable [Judge's Last Name]" or "Dear Judge [Last Name]." Date it. Include your contact information: some judges' staff do verify letters, and an unreachable writer looks like a fictional one.
Send the letter to the defense attorney, not directly to the judge. The attorney collects the letters, reviews them, and submits them as a package with the sentencing materials. This is standard practice and it protects you: the attorney will catch anything in your draft that could backfire before the judge ever sees it. Ask the attorney for the deadline well in advance; sentencing dates move, and a late letter may not make the packet.
Ready to mail it? Send your letter with LetterAgent: describe it to your AI assistant, approve the exact quoted price, and it is printed and mailed.
LetterAgent is a working name. Prices include print, postage, and our service fee. US prices in USD, Canadian prices in CAD (Canadian prices exclude applicable sales tax, added at checkout). Currently in private testing.
Need help? Ask your assistant: it can check a job's status any time. If it ever can't handle something: hello@getletteragent.com